Magento API not working with wsdl.exe but works with Soap UI

Magento API not working with wsdl.exe but works with Soap UI

September 19, 2026 · Illustrated author avatarBy Stefan Bogdanescu
Magento API not working with wsdl.exe but works with Soap UI

Integrating Magento with C# Applications: Solving WSDL Exe vs Soap UI Challenges

Developing integration solutions between e-commerce platforms like Magento and enterprise applications can be complex due to the variety of available tools and their compatibility quirks. In this post, we’ll explore a common issue where Visual Studio’s “Add Service Reference” utility fails to generate proxies for a Magento API while Soap UI succeeds.

The Scenario You’re attempting to integrate a C# application with Magento 1.7 using the Add Service Reference function in Visual Studio but encountering an error:

  • The Reference.cs file is almost empty after clicking “OK”.
  • Running wsdl.exe from the command prompt results in errors related to binding and port operations.

Understanding the Error The core issue lies in the WSDL file structure generated by Magento. The API description contains operations with no matching bindings, which violates WS-I Basic Profile v1.1 specifications.

The error message states:

R2718: A wsdl:binding in a DESCRIPTION MUST have the same set of wsdl:operations as the wsdl:portType to which it refers.

  • Operation ‘catalogProductAttributeRemove’ on portType ‘Mage_Api_Model_Server_Wsi_HandlerPortType’ from namespace ‘urn:Magento’ has no matching binding.

Why Soap UI Succeeds Where Visual Studio Fails Soap UI’s WSDL parser is more lenient and can tolerate these discrepancies in the schema. It ignores the missing binding operations, allowing you to proceed with API calls. In contrast, Visual Studio’s service reference generator is stricter and adheres closely to WS-I standards.

Solving the Issue: Manual Proxy Generation To resolve this issue without relying on the automated tools:

  1. Download the WSDL: Obtain the Magento API WSDL file (https://gist.github.com/4514723).

  2. Use WCF Test Client: Install the WCF Test Client from NuGet (Install-Package Microsoft.WCF.TestClient -Version 4.8.0). This tool provides a more flexible approach to consume web services.

  3. Create a Service Model: Open Visual Studio and create a new C# Console Application. Add a reference to System.ServiceModel.

  4. Configure the Client: Create a ServiceModel class with the following configuration:

public static void Main(string[] args)
{
    var binding = new BasicHttpBinding();
    binding.Security.Mode = BasicHttpSecurityMode.None;

    var endpointAddress = "http://your_magento_url/api/soap/?wsdl";

    var factory = new ChannelFactory<IMageApiModelServerWsiHandlerPortType>(binding, new EndpointAddress(endpointAddress));
    var client = factory.CreateChannel();

    // Use the client to make API calls
}

Conclusion In this scenario, the issue lies in the Magento API’s WSDL file structure rather than your C# application. While Soap UI can work around these inconsistencies, Visual Studio’s service reference generator is more strict.

To integrate with the Magento API effectively:

  1. Understand the nuances of your integration tools’ compatibility.
  2. Be prepared to manually generate proxies using more flexible tools like WCF Test Client or Soap UI when necessary.
  3. Always validate and test the generated code thoroughly before production deployment.

For further guidance on enterprise-level e-commerce integrations, explore our comprehensive resources at Laravel Company.

Magento 1 Catalog API Errors

Our network