why magento using other product's url key for url rewrite

why magento using other product's url key for url rewrite

September 14, 2026 · Illustrated author avatarBy Stefan Bogdanescu
why magento using other product's url key for url rewrite

Magento: Resolving Duplicate Product URLs with Incorrect URL Keys

Are you facing issues with Magento generating duplicate product URLs using incorrect URL keys? This common problem can lead to broken links, confusion for customers, and potential SEO penalties. In this guide, we’ll explore the root cause of this issue in Magento 1.7 and provide step-by-step solutions.

Understanding the Problem: Incorrect URL Keys and Random Numbers

The primary culprit behind this issue is how Magento manages its URL rewrite system. When a new product is created with an existing URL key, Magento attempts to generate a unique URL by appending a random number to the end of the original key.

For example:

  • Existing product: Name = “Example”, URL Key = “example”
  • Newly created product: Name = “XYZ”, URL Key = “example” (same as existing product)

Instead of generating a new and unique URL like www.example.com/xyz, Magento creates a duplicate with an appended random number: www.example.com/example-123.

Identifying the Root Cause

The problem lies in how Magento handles URL keys that are not unique. When reindexing or saving products, Magento checks for existing URLs and generates duplicates if a match is found.

The Contributing Factors

  1. Non-Unique URL Keys: If you have multiple products with identical URL keys, the system will generate duplicates.
  2. Incorrect SEO Settings: Incorrect settings in Magento’s SEO configuration can lead to this issue.
  3. Incomplete Reindexing: Failing to reindex properly after changes can cause persistent issues.

Step-by-Step Solutions

Solution 1: Ensure Unique URL Keys for All Products

To prevent duplicates, always ensure that each product has a unique and descriptive URL key:

  1. From your Magento admin panel, navigate to Catalog > Manage Products.
  2. Edit each existing product to make sure its URL Key is distinct.
  3. When creating new products, carefully choose unique URL keys.

Solution 2: Reindex URLs Properly

Proper reindexing is crucial for Magento’s URL system:

  1. From your admin panel, go to System > Index Management.
  2. Click the “Reindex All” button in the top right corner.
  3. Wait for the process to complete (this may take some time).
  4. Verify that all indexes are marked as “Ready”.

Solution 3: Clear Cache and Rewrite URLs Table

Sometimes, Magento’s cache can interfere with URL generation:

  1. From your admin panel, go to System > Cache Management.
  2. Click the “Flush Magento Cache” button.
  3. Additionally, clear the browser cache.

If reindexing doesn’t resolve duplicates, consider clearing the rewrite_urls table:

  1. Log in to your database using PHPMyAdmin or a similar tool.
  2. Select the rewrite_urls table.
  3. Click “Empty” to remove all records.
  4. Reindex URLs again from the admin panel.

Conclusion: Maintaining URL Integrity in Magento

To maintain clean and SEO-friendly URLs, always adhere to these best practices:

  • Use unique URL keys for each product.
  • Regularly reindex your Magento store.
  • Clear cache periodically to ensure optimal performance.
  • Double-check SEO settings to avoid common configuration issues.

Remember, proper URL management is crucial for a seamless user experience and effective SEO. If you’re still facing difficulties or need further assistance with Magento customization and optimization, don’t hesitate to contact our team at Laravel Company.

We specialize in providing expert Magento development services, from initial setup to complex customizations and integrations. Let us help you achieve your e-commerce goals with a robust and optimized Magento platform.

Additional Resources

For more detailed guides on Magento SEO optimization and URL management, check out these resources:

Magento 1 Catalog Indexing Configuration

Our network