Should Magento's blank theme still be used as a theme baseline (Magento version 1.7)?

Should Magento's blank theme still be used as a theme baseline (Magento version 1.7)?

August 7, 2026 · Illustrated author avatarBy Stefan Bogdanescu
Should Magento's blank theme still be used as a theme baseline (Magento version 1.7)?

Magento Theme Development: The Case for Blank vs Luma

As a senior developer, I often get asked about the best way to start a new theme project in Magento. One of the most common pieces of advice is to use the “blank” theme as a baseline or starting point. While this approach was once standard practice, it’s time we reevaluate its effectiveness in the context of modern Magento development.

The Problem with Using Blank

The primary issue with using the blank theme as a base lies in its architecture and codebase. This theme is built on top of the default theme, which contains a significant amount of core functionality that you may not need or want in your custom project. By starting with blank, you’re inheriting this unnecessary baggage.

For example, let’s look at the page layout files located in app/design/frontend/base/default/layout:

<layouts>
  <default>
    <reference name="head">
      <action method="addJs"><file>js/mage/cookies.js</file></action>
      <action method="setTitle" translate="title"><title>Home Page</title></action>
    </reference>
    <reference name="left">
      <block type="catalog/navigation" name="catalog.leftnav"/>
    </reference>
  </default>
  <!-- More layout xml files -->
</layouts>

As you can see, there’s a lot of Magento-specific configuration and blocks being added to the default page layout. If your theme doesn’t require these elements (for instance, if it’s a headless setup or a PWA), you’re better off starting with a cleaner slate.

Introducing Luma: A Better Alternative

The luma theme was introduced in Magento 2 as part of an effort to create a more modular and flexible base architecture. Unlike blank, which builds on top of default, luma is designed to be used as a standalone base theme.

Some key advantages of using luma include:

  1. Cleaner codebase: Luma has significantly less “baggage” than the default or blank themes.
  2. Better performance: With fewer dependencies and unnecessary files, your theme will load faster.
  3. Less conflict potential: When you’re working on a custom theme, there’s less chance of code conflicts with Magento core functionality.

Best Practices for Theme Development

If starting from scratch is too daunting, here are some best practices to minimize the impact of using blank or luma:

  1. Create a completely new theme folder (e.g., app/design/frontend/YourVendor/YourTheme) and copy only the necessary files from your chosen base theme.
  2. Use a version control system like Git to track changes and make it easier to revert if needed.
  3. Minimize the number of Magento core files you override, as this can lead to upgrade issues.

Conclusion: The Case for Luma

In summary, while using the blank theme was once recommended for theme development in earlier versions of Magento, modern best practices suggest starting with a cleaner base like luma.

Starting from scratch or using a minimalistic base can lead to:

  • Improved performance due to lighter file sizes
  • Reduced risk of conflicts between your custom code and Magento core
  • A better understanding of Magento’s architecture

Remember, the goal is to create a lean, efficient theme that meets your project’s specific needs. Don’t hesitate to take advantage of resources like Laravel Company’s Magento development services if you need expert guidance.

Happy theming!

Magento 1 Catalog Themes Configuration

Our network